CONSOL ENERGY INC

CUSIP: 20854P109 Class: COM

PERMIT CAPITAL, LLC's Holding History (CIK: 0001313978)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q2 2015
Shares 5,950 Value ($000) $129 Avg Close — Range —
Q1 2015
Shares 5,950 Value ($000) $166 Avg Close — Range —
Q4 2014
Shares 5,950 Value ($000) $201 Avg Close — Range —
Q3 2014
Shares 5,950 Value ($000) $225 Avg Close — Range —
Q2 2014
Shares 5,950 Value ($000) $274 Avg Close — Range —
Q1 2014
Shares 5,950 Value ($000) $238 Avg Close — Range —
Q4 2013
Shares 5,920 Value ($000) $225 Avg Close — Range —
Q3 2013
Shares 4,970 Value ($000) $167 Avg Close — Range —
Q2 2013
Shares 4,700 Value ($000) $127 Avg Close — Range —