CONSOL ENERGY INC

CUSIP: 20854P109 Class: COM

APG Asset Management N.V.'s Holding History (CIK: 0001434819)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q3 2015
Shares 337,859 Value ($000) $3,311 Avg Close — Range —
Q2 2015
Shares 389,321 Value ($000) $8,464 Avg Close — Range —
Q1 2015
Shares 411,860 Value ($000) $11,487 Avg Close — Range —
Q4 2014
Shares 394,988 Value ($000) $13,355 Avg Close — Range —
Q3 2014
Shares 404,545 Value ($000) $15,316 Avg Close — Range —
Q2 2014
Shares 350,108 Value ($000) $16,129 Avg Close — Range —
Q1 2014
Shares 201,518 Value ($000) $8,051 Avg Close — Range —
Q4 2013
Shares 201,518 Value ($000) $7,666 Avg Close — Range —
Q3 2013
Shares 226,504 Value ($000) $7,622 Avg Close — Range —
Q2 2013
Shares 280,610 Value ($000) $7,605 Avg Close — Range —