NOBLE ENERGY INC

CUSIP: 655044105 Class: COM

BECK MACK & OLIVER LLC's Holding History (CIK: 0000010742)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q1 2016
Shares 8,000 Value ($000) $251 Avg Close — Range —
Q4 2015
Shares 11,000 Value ($000) $362 Avg Close — Range —
Q3 2015
Shares 71,000 Value ($000) $2,143 Avg Close — Range —
Q2 2015
Shares 73,000 Value ($000) $3,116 Avg Close — Range —
Q1 2015
Shares 73,000 Value ($000) $3,570 Avg Close — Range —
Q4 2014
Shares 73,250 Value ($000) $3,474 Avg Close — Range —
Q3 2014
Shares 73,250 Value ($000) $5,007 Avg Close — Range —
Q2 2014
Shares 73,250 Value ($000) $5,674 Avg Close — Range —
Q1 2014
Shares 13,250 Value ($000) $941 Avg Close — Range —
Q4 2013
Shares 12,750 Value ($000) $868 Avg Close — Range —
Q3 2013
Shares 12,750 Value ($000) $854 Avg Close — Range —
Q2 2013
Shares 12,750 Value ($000) $766 Avg Close — Range —