PBF ENERGY INC

Ticker: PBF CUSIP: 69318G106 Class: Common Stock

FIRST MANHATTAN CO. LLC.'s Holding History (CIK: 0000728083)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q4 2017

Shares 955 Value ($000) $33 Avg Close $30.91 Range $26.24 - $36.07

Q3 2017

Shares 955 Value ($000) $26 Avg Close $23.15 Range $19.46 - $28.31

Q2 2017

Shares 955 Value ($000) $21 Avg Close $21.47 Range $18.48 - $23.52

Q1 2017

Shares 955 Value ($000) $21 Avg Close $23.44 Range $20.44 - $28.92

Q4 2016

Shares 955 Value ($000) $26 Avg Close $24.39 Range $19.47 - $30.98

Period	Shares	Value ($000)	Average Close	Price Range
Q4 2017	955	$33	$30.91	$26.24 - $36.07
Q3 2017	955	$26	$23.15	$19.46 - $28.31
Q2 2017	955	$21	$21.47	$18.48 - $23.52
Q1 2017	955	$21	$23.44	$20.44 - $28.92
Q4 2016	955	$26	$24.39	$19.47 - $30.98