PENSKE AUTOMOTIVE GRP INC

Ticker: PAG CUSIP: 70959W103 Class: Stock

MACKAY SHIELDS LLC's Holding History (CIK: 0000061227)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q4 2019

Shares 68,815 Value ($000) $3,456 Avg Close $49.44 Range $42.41 - $53.81

Q3 2019

Shares 7,760 Value ($000) $367 Avg Close $45.23 Range $41.26 - $49.28

Q1 2019

Shares 6,456 Value ($000) $288 Avg Close $44.30 Range $39.93 - $48.55

Q4 2018

Shares 20,059 Value ($000) $809 Avg Close $43.24 Range $38.49 - $48.58

Q3 2018

Shares 11,031 Value ($000) $523 Avg Close $50.84 Range $46.32 - $53.84

Period	Shares	Value ($000)	Average Close	Price Range
Q4 2019	68,815	$3,456	$49.44	$42.41 - $53.81
Q3 2019	7,760	$367	$45.23	$41.26 - $49.28
Q1 2019	6,456	$288	$44.30	$39.93 - $48.55
Q4 2018	20,059	$809	$43.24	$38.49 - $48.58
Q3 2018	11,031	$523	$50.84	$46.32 - $53.84