PROVIDENT FINL SVCS INC

Ticker: PFS CUSIP: 74386T105 Class: Common Stock

North Star Investment Management Corp.'s Holding History (CIK: 0001342857)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q3 2015

Shares 540 Value ($000) $11 Avg Close $11.92 Range $11.40 - $12.44

Q2 2015

Shares 540 Value ($000) $10 Avg Close $11.40 Range $10.85 - $12.16

Q1 2015

Shares 540 Value ($000) $10 Avg Close $11.05 Range $10.24 - $11.68

Q4 2014

Shares 540 Value ($000) $10 Avg Close $10.58 Range $9.72 - $11.19

Period	Shares	Value ($000)	Average Close	Price Range
Q3 2015	540	$11	$11.92	$11.40 - $12.44
Q2 2015	540	$10	$11.40	$10.85 - $12.16
Q1 2015	540	$10	$11.05	$10.24 - $11.68
Q4 2014	540	$10	$10.58	$9.72 - $11.19