VALERO ENERGY CORP

Ticker: VLO CUSIP: 91913Y100 Class: COM

CORSAIR CAPITAL MANAGEMENT, L.P.'s Holding History (CIK: 0001276470)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q3 2016

Shares 28,281 Value ($000) $1,499 Avg Close $36.73 Range $32.07 - $40.18

Q2 2016

Shares 28,281 Value ($000) $1,442 Avg Close $38.47 Range $34.15 - $43.36

Q1 2016

Shares 28,281 Value ($000) $1,814 Avg Close $42.88 Range $35.57 - $48.59

Q4 2015

Shares 28,281 Value ($000) $2,000 Avg Close $45.50 Range $39.25 - $49.52

Q3 2015

Shares 30,784 Value ($000) $1,850 Avg Close $42.17 Range $34.39 - $47.58

Q1 2015

Shares 30,563 Value ($000) $1,944 Avg Close $36.56 Range $28.33 - $42.36

Q4 2014

Shares 30,563 Value ($000) $1,513 Avg Close $31.49 Range $27.58 - $33.97

Q3 2014

Shares 40,563 Value ($000) $1,877 Avg Close $32.63 Range $29.66 - $35.41

Q2 2014

Shares 40,563 Value ($000) $2,032 Avg Close $35.48 Range $32.27 - $38.33

Q1 2014

Shares 20,563 Value ($000) $1,092 Avg Close $32.81 Range $29.32 - $35.94

Q4 2013

Shares 20,453 Value ($000) $1,031 Avg Close $26.85 Range $21.10 - $32.29

Q3 2013

Shares 20,453 Value ($000) $698 Avg Close $22.41 Range $20.85 - $23.70

Q2 2013

Shares 20,227 Value ($000) $703 Avg Close $24.01 Range $21.02 - $26.98

Period	Shares	Value ($000)	Average Close	Price Range
Q3 2016	28,281	$1,499	$36.73	$32.07 - $40.18
Q2 2016	28,281	$1,442	$38.47	$34.15 - $43.36
Q1 2016	28,281	$1,814	$42.88	$35.57 - $48.59
Q4 2015	28,281	$2,000	$45.50	$39.25 - $49.52
Q3 2015	30,784	$1,850	$42.17	$34.39 - $47.58
Q1 2015	30,563	$1,944	$36.56	$28.33 - $42.36
Q4 2014	30,563	$1,513	$31.49	$27.58 - $33.97
Q3 2014	40,563	$1,877	$32.63	$29.66 - $35.41
Q2 2014	40,563	$2,032	$35.48	$32.27 - $38.33
Q1 2014	20,563	$1,092	$32.81	$29.32 - $35.94
Q4 2013	20,453	$1,031	$26.85	$21.10 - $32.29
Q3 2013	20,453	$698	$22.41	$20.85 - $23.70
Q2 2013	20,227	$703	$24.01	$21.02 - $26.98