VALERO ENERGY CORP

Ticker: VLO CUSIP: 91913Y100 Class: COM

Winthrop Partners - WNY, LLC's Holding History (CIK: 0001734109)

Note: Option positions (PUT/CALL) are excluded.

Q1 2019

Shares 23 Value ($000) $1,987 Avg Close $62.40 Range $54.76 - $66.74

Q4 2018

Shares 23 Value ($000) $1,724 Avg Close $65.55 Range $51.65 - $89.76

Q3 2018

Shares 23 Value ($000) $2,616 Avg Close $84.22 Range $76.60 - $91.02

Q2 2018

Shares 23 Value ($000) $2,549 Avg Close $82.55 Range $65.81 - $93.76

Q1 2018

Shares 23 Value ($000) $2,208 Avg Close $68.16 Range $60.24 - $72.63

Period	Shares	Value ($000)	Average Close	Price Range
Q1 2019	23	$1,987	$62.40	$54.76 - $66.74
Q4 2018	23	$1,724	$65.55	$51.65 - $89.76
Q3 2018	23	$2,616	$84.22	$76.60 - $91.02
Q2 2018	23	$2,549	$82.55	$65.81 - $93.76
Q1 2018	23	$2,208	$68.16	$60.24 - $72.63